Quantcast University Journal

OP-ED: Bigger view needed on immigration

Collge Republicans

Issue date: 3/25/08 Section: Opinion
  • Print
  • Email
  • Page 1 of 1
We have been following the series of articles that gives different perspectives of illegal immigration in respect to southern Utah. The articles are very informative and they give the readers an opportunity to see this issue of illegal immigration on a personal level.

While it is easy to feel bad about the situation when seen through a magnifying glass, the College Republicans feel that it is important to step back and discuss this issue in terms that include our country as a whole. When seen from a larger scale, it is apparent that illegal immigration has negative effects on the U.S. that can be felt by each of us in many ways.

One major cost that comes along with a porous border is that of our education system.

As America's youth struggles to keep up with students from other countries from an academic standpoint, it's hard to ignore the fact that we are spending over $30 billion a year educating children of illegal immigrants. This doesn't even include the amount spent providing these children with school lunches and other welfare benefits that are included in school budgets.

In addition to the higher costs of education, these immigrants are not required to contribute to the funding of their children's education because they are not required to pay taxes.

In addition to the money being taken directly out of our education system, we need to think about the money being taken out of our economy as well. Although we are the richest country in the world, we have poor people just like any other country, and we simply cannot afford to support any poor person that wants to come here.

As millions of illegal immigrants work in America, many of them are simply taking money out of our economy. It is said that somewhere between $6 to $8 billion a year is leaving our country and being sent south to Mexico to help support the Mexican economy. This is a Mexican economy that is rich in natural resources and oil with all the potential to become a super power throughout the globe, yet because they have corrupt leadership and a thoroughly incompetent government we are forced to take care of their citizens. It just doesn't seem right.

While education and the economy remains a problem inside our borders, outside of the country we are also fighting a war on terror. As evidenced by the Sept. 11 attacks, the threat of terrorism and American hate is as clear today as ever.

It is pretty clear that if we have people crossing the border illegally just to go to work, then terrorists with a burning determination to destroy this country will have no problem getting into America.

There are other issues that have gone untouched such as crime rates, jobs, and health care, each affecting us on an everyday basis, and it is important not to overlook these issues when thinking of illegal immigration.

The SUU College Republicans can be contacted through its president, Steve Spooner, a senior accounting major from Cedar City, at spoons_1186@yahoo.com.
Page 1 of 1

Article Tools

Viewing Comments 1 - 10 of 30

JD

posted 3/25/08 @ 9:32 AM MST

The $6 to $8 Billion estimate on monies sent OUT of the U.S. to Mexico is a huge underestimation.

Mexico receives OVER $20 BILLION annually in the form of remittances from legal and illegal aliens living in the United States. (Continued…)

Bobby

posted 3/25/08 @ 11:49 AM MST

Here is the ONLY legitimate view on illegal immigration. IT'S AGAINST EXISTING IMMIGRATION LAW, WHICH SAYS THAT THOSE WHO ENABLE IT ARE ACTING CRIMINALLY AND SHOULD BE PUNISHED. (Continued…)

Delaware Bob

posted 3/25/08 @ 12:17 PM MST

This story is almost 100% TRUE.

Did it ever occur to you how many Americans are put out of work because if these ILLEGAL ALIENS? Are you happy with the $300 million sent to Mexico every year?, money we will NEVER see again. (Continued…)

(1 reply)   Details   Reply to this comment

Bettybb

Bettybb

posted 3/25/08 @ 1:48 PM MST

Excellent article.

The whole issue of the free trade goal of special interests, and the Mexican goal of gradually taking over of the USA should also be adressed. (Continued…)

Bettybb

posted 3/25/08 @ 1:55 PM MST

Sorry for the double post, I thought the first one had not gone through.

RSG

posted 3/25/08 @ 2:32 PM MST

Mexicans in the USA (legal but mostly illegal), send back 20-24 BILLION per year.

Furthermore, a large percentage of all so called "Hispanics" are illegal aliens, illegal aliens are usually using fake or stolen ID's, comitting social security fraud, driving without a license, insurance, etc. (Continued…)

LadyM

LadyM

posted 3/25/08 @ 4:30 PM MST

In 2006 $23 Billion was sent to Mexico and in 2007 it was $25 Billion. Yes that's Billion, not million. This source of revenue was only second to the revenue generated by oil sales. (Continued…)

Bettybb

posted 3/25/08 @ 4:38 PM MST

States that have recently returned to the American values of the rule of law and equal treatment for all, have found a hidden bonus in the self deportation of illegal aliens. (Continued…)

Delaware Bob

posted 3/25/08 @ 7:42 PM MST

LadyM
posted 3/25/08 @ 4:19 PM MST

Thank You for the correction. I didn't think it was that much! We see all kind of figures tossed around.
The bottom line is this ILLEGAL IMMIGRATION is taking us to bankruptcy, and our Federal government doesn't seen to care. (Continued…)

William Garland

posted 3/26/08 @ 8:22 AM MST

Not all aliens improperly present in the US have committed a crime. Under 8 U.S.C. 1325 illegal entry is a federal misdemeanor for the first violation and felony for second ones. (Continued…)

Post a Comment

  • NOTE: Email address will not be published

Type your comment below (html not allowed)

  I understand posting spam or other comments that are unrelated to this article will cause my comment to be flagged for deletion and possibly cause my IP address to be permanently banned from this server.

Advertisement

Poll

Are you voting in the 2008 General Election?
Submit Vote

View Results

Advertisement